A New Vision on Cooperation: How Our Greatest Strength Became Our Weakness

Humans never learned to genuinely collaborate.  They became good at forming tight clans who mobilised their members against other clans, against the planet, and ultimately against all members of their own clan who had refused to “cooperate”.  Efficient, outcome-based cooperation always requires a level of top-down control over the clan’s members, and this is why today’s corporate structures are highly totalitarian.

And yet, our culture holds an idealized view of cooperation: that it is always democratic, egalitarian, and respectful of the individual within the group.  Countless new apostles spring up each day preaching how compassionate humans are when they come together, forgetting that cooperation is not an altruistic pursuit but a survival tactic that emerged as a war skill: groups that cooperated most effectively killed more enemies, found more food, and were able to specialise and form complex societies – giving them an unparalleled advantage against other tribes. Most of all, they were highly efficient in silencing dissent.

People cooperated so they could build the pyramids of Egypt, send missions to the moon, and discover the structure of the nucleic acid code. They also cooperated so they could drive countless species to extinction, create the world’s first atomic bomb, and attack other nations who were also cooperating amongst themselves, and towards a common enemy.

We are also the only species with countries and borders. Within a single country, one can praise peoples’ ability to come together and cooperate under a flag, religion, or purpose. But when you look at the big picture, cooperation is nothing but a weapon: it is constantly misused, abused, and mass produced. Israelis cooperated with each other so they can make the Palestinian nation extinct. For Palestinians, this was extermination. For Israelis, it was cooperation and compassion: the power of people coming together in unity towards a common goal.

Human civilisation became a dreaded Mafia state in the ecosystem, exactly because of its incredible propensity for cooperation: this allowed the formation of tightly knit, exclusive groups that embezzled natural resources, blackmailed other lifeforms into flight, kept all profits in-house, and killed all the competition. We are collectively the biggest Mafia that has existed on the planet.

In biological terms, cooperation is a behavioural pattern – not a charity. Cooperation skills developed first and foremost as a survival strategy, not an ethical code. Today, humans are cooperating on an extractive, global planetary demolition project which is bringing down entire ecosystems and even the climate system that allowed the development of life on the planet in the first place.  So, the idea proposed by many that, in times of crises, we tend to pursue “good” forms of cooperation, finds me diametrically opposed.  We pursue neither “good” or “bad” forms of cooperation, but collaboration that ensures survival, even if this means the death of enemies and ecosystems that get in the way.  In a time of crisis resources dwindle and competition tightens. It is not a time to make friends, but to make allies.  When strapped for resources, humans always declare war on nature, and on each other.

What is important to recognize is that we only ever collaborate when there is a reward and an outcome expected: either a personal benefit, or a wider benefit for the group that we are part of. Either way, each member of the group expects to benefit directly or indirectly as a result of their participation. The closer they are to the “carrot”, the stronger their willingness and affinity for collaboration with the rest of the group.  An individual will continue to work collaboratively within a group only when they are getting something back. Those in charge of the group – be it leaders, clerics, employers or economic hegemons – must devise ways to blackmail the rest of the group or keep it hostage with salaries and other mechanisms. This is what they’ve been doing for thousands of years.

People don’t form groups and alliances as a form of peace-making. They are organising themselves to survive against real or perceived threats.  Realising this can fundamentally change our discourse around cooperation, envisaging ways to collaborate that are more democratic and widen the group of benefactors to include all humans, and all species. Cooperation in itself isn’t bad.  Humans getting together to hurt other humans, and other life forms, is. Cooperation has never been selfless, and it shouldn’t be.  People should have a reason and a vested interest to collaborate, but in a world where we are connected by the same crises, wherever we live, the only cooperation that makes sense is one where our individual interests do not rival those of others, and those of the living planet. If we could see the whole planet with all its species as one clan, a single tribe, then this would conceivably be possible. We need to make selfishness shameful again: identify, isolate, extricate and disempower all institutions and individuals who manipulate groups of people and other beings for their own selfish benefit.  If this civilisation is to survive, then the only type of benefit from collaboration should be one that is collective:  benefiting all individuals and all life forms, however hard they worked.  In a capitalist system this is considered “unfair”.  In an ecosystem, this is considered essential. 

In 2026 (The Biology of Collapse) I wrote: The bottom line today is that humans are unwanted, undesirable, and worthless to this planet. As we toy with our own extinction, our only chance of remaining in existence is if we end our war with Earth and make ourselves useful to the ecosystem again.

Can our biology accommodate this?

Thank you for reading. You may have noticed the paywalls on my newsletter.

They are not there to deprive you of insight, turn my readership into an exclusive club for the wealthy, or demonstrate how greedy I am.

They are there for a much simpler reason: the paywall is what pays my electric bill and allows me to continue writing.

Those of you who have become paid subscribers deserve the exclusive access to my archive that you have. Without your support, there would be no newsletter at all.

Thank you.


Discover more from George Tsakraklides

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply